Your buyer doesn’t experience attribution channels, they experience one Search results page, top to bottom, in a single glance. Your classic organic ranking isn’t competing against 9 other rankings anymore.
It’s competing against ads, an AI answer, videos, and forum threads – all on the same screen, in a single glance.
Visibility isn’t about ranking positions anymore, it’s how much of the screen you occupy.
We took 1,500 mid-to-bottom-funnel queries across 8 HR work-tech categories and looked at what a buyer actually sees when they search on Google. Not just the organic rankings, the whole page.
About the Search Visibility Index
We analyzed these software categories:
- Frontline & Deskless Workforce
- L&D and Upskilling
- Talent Acquisition & AI Recruiting
- HRIS & Core People Platforms
- Payroll & Benefits
- Performance, Engagement & Culture
- People Analytics & Workforce Intelligence
- Global Employment & EOR
Here’s what shows up across those 1,500 queries:

That is 5 potential search features that appear before organic results, or at the very least mixed in.
For 69% of the queries we ran, three or more of these features appeared – meaning organic listings were well below the fold.
This is not a call to abandon organic in favor of these features, as this study shows that there is overlap between ranked URLs and those cited in AI Overview. Similar to the study we did comparing AI Mode to AI Overview and Organic. This is a call to broaden your scope on what visibility means, especially when referring to high-intent keywords.
A strategy that brings together paid, organic, social, brand (PR), and community will always win. The catch is that hardly anyone manages it, because it demands the internal alignment, resources, and focus that most teams simply don’t have.

Here is what you will learn in this article:
- The search results page for HR and work tech is dominated by Rippling, BambooHR, ADP and Workday because of what they do right.
- 94% of brands recommended in AI Overviews rank on page 1 somewhere across our queries. AI isn’t mirroring the results for each search, it’s rewarding brands that are known across the category.
- You don’t need one version of your content for organic and another for AI. Build what the buyer needs at that stage, and both will pick it up.
- Video remains the most under-invested content format.
- One of the biggest winners in organic and AI isn’t a traditional publisher or vendor, but rather a community: Reddit.
Key Findings
#1 Each Search feature has a different winner
We expected some overlap between brands across search features. Instead, each one came back with its own set of winners (domains and brands that appeared most often). The ad auction has one leader, the AI’s recommendations another, and neither matches the publishers the AI cites or the sites winning the organic links. 3 search features, 4 different lists, all stacked in front of the same buyer.
Look at who leads each one, by how many queries they reach:

Publishers, such as YouTube, Reddit, Gartner, G2, etc, dominate what the AI cites as sources and organic links, but they’re never recommended and never appear in paid.
This split isn’t random, and it’s not really surprising once you look at who these brands are. Publishers don’t need ads to make money, their visibility is the product. They rank, they get cited, and they monetise that attention directly.
Vendors like Deel and BambooHR don’t own that visibility, so they only have two ways to get in front of the same buyer: pay for it (premium placement on G2, ad space on Google) or earn it (build enough brand that they get pulled into organic results and named in AI recommendations).
The brands the AI actually names are all vendors, and some barely register as cited sources at all. AI results split cleanly: publishers supply the reading material; vendors get the recommendation.
Only 5% of domains appear on all three search features. Winning one doesn’t hand you the others: the brand that tops the ad auction isn’t the one the AI names, and the sites the AI cites aren’t the ones it recommends.
The vendors to watch. Four SaaS brands carry the widest footprint in the study: Deel, ADP, BambooHR and Rippling. Between them, they cover every surface, but no one brand covers them all.
Deel wins paid, Rippling leads the AI recommendations, ADP has the deepest organic reach, and BambooHR is the only one placing near the top of two at once. Even the strongest vendors are winning one surface each.

What does this mean for your go-to-market strategy?
Google isn’t one race, it’s three: organic, paid, and AI answers, each won by a different set of competitors. That’s why your SEO lead can report a record month while a competitor owns the ad and the AI answer sitting directly above your organic result on the same query.
Stop reporting by channel, and start reporting by query. Build one report (in Looker Studio, or straight in AI via MCPs) that pulls organic data from Google Search Console, paid from Google Ads, engagement from GA4, and your preferred AI visibility tracking tool (ours is Peec), then score how much of each priority query you actually own across all three channels.
That score shows you where you’re losing, not why. To see what the internet says about your brand before a buyer ever reaches you, run a digital footprint audit.
#2 Organic ranking is the entry ticket to AI visibility
94% of brands recommended in AI Overviews rank on page 1 somewhere across our queries.
Here’s the catch: that page 1 presence is category-wide, not query-specific. Yes, 89% of AI-recommended brands rank in the top 10 for some query in their category. But tie each recommendation to the exact query it answered, and only about a third still rank on page 1.
AI isn’t mirroring the results for each search. It’s rewarding brands that are known across the category.

That reframes what winning looks like. Take your highest-intent keyword. “Onboarding software,” say, the term you’ve chased for years. If you can’t crack page 1 anymore, that used to be the end of the story. Now, it isn’t. You may never rank on that page again, but you can still be the brand named at the top of the AI answer for it – as long as you’ve built enough category-wide presence that the AI reads you as a leader.
What does this mean for your go-to-market strategy?
Getting there changes two things: what you make, and what you measure.
What you make has to diversify. Rank for the adjacent, winnable keywords around the head term, the ones you can actually still win. And earn the mentions, backlinks and reviews that mark you as a known name: listicles, G2, Capterra, Gartner, wherever your buyers go to look.
Content and mentions together, not one or the other. Paid earns its place here too, holding the head term you can’t win organically while it builds the category authority AI reads. The brand has to hold up everywhere it lives, owned, rented and borrowed.
What you measure has to change with it. For the pages you can realistically win, keep scoring them by rank, that part hasn’t changed. For the high-intent pages you’ll never top again, you need a second scorecard, one built on presence: are you named in the AI answer, are you cited, are you recommended?
If you keep grading those pages by rank alone, your report will show a column full of losses on exactly the terms where you’ve claimed the only spot left worth claiming.
Ranking for the exact term is no longer the only door in. Being known across the category is the other.
#3 Build for the buyer (both organic and AI reward it)
Finding #2 was about who gets named. This one is about what you put in front of them. Want to know what content to make for a query? Look at what Search already serves for it.
Every stage of the journey has an asset that wins. And here’s the part we didn’t expect: organic and AI mostly agree on which one.
Here is how we defined Search intent:
- Middle Of Funnel – “What is X”, “how does X work” educational, pre-shortlist
- Bottom Of Funnel – Category/solution terms a buyer searches when actively evaluating
- Comparative – “X vs Y”, “best X”, “alternatives” implying explicit shortlisting
- Pricing – “X pricing”, “X cost”
- Reviews – “X reviews”, “is X good”
- Demo -“X demo”, “free trial”
Five of the six intents we tracked, they picked the same winner: an explainer article while the buyer’s still learning, and a third-party listicle when they’re comparing, reading reviews, or cutting down a shortlist. They only split right at the end, when someone wants to try: organic points to a product page, AI reaches for video.
Two systems, pulling from two different places, agreeing almost the whole way down.
Here is how we define the content types to make:
- Article – Educational / explainer content that is NOT a ranked product list
- Listicle – A ‘Top 10 / Best X’ roundup whose primary purpose is ranking
- Product page – Vendor page describing a specific product, feature, solution, or industry use case; conversion-oriented.
- Video – YouTube, Vimeo, or any other video hosting platform
- Landing page – A dedicated landing page (often an ad destination), distinct from a standard product page
So you don’t need one version of your content for organic and another for AI. Build what the buyer needs at that stage, and both pick it up. We can see it on the page: 27% of earned pages show up in organic and the AI Overview at once. Same URL, two placements, no extra production.

Paid is the odd one out. Whatever the buyer’s after, the ad sends them to a landing page: 66% of the time when they’re comparing, 70% at reviews, 82% at demo. Sometimes that’s right. Someone ready to book a demo is happy to land on a page built to convert them. But earlier? It’s a potential mismatch. They came to compare five options and you’ve dropped them on one.
The data only tells us paid runs on landing pages, not that it’s costing you. But my instinct says it’s worth testing. If organic and AI both answer a comparison query with a comparison, maybe your ad shouldn’t answer it with a single-vendor page. The stage might reward a different asset here too, a comparison or a short demo video.
So the takeaway isn’t to make more content. It’s to make the right asset, once. Match it to what the buyer’s actually asking, and organic and AI both reward you. A caution on listicles: earn your place in credible third-party ones rather than spinning up your own, Google began cracking down on self-promotional roundups in early 2026
What does this mean for your go-to-market strategy?
Plan by buying stage, not by channel. One explainer for the learning stage, one comparison asset for the shortlist, one demo asset for the buyer who’s ready. Each built once, rewarded twice.
The comparison and review stages mostly live on third-party sites (G2, Gartner, the big listicles), so that’s a reviews and analyst-relations job as much as a content one. And let paid do what it’s good at: holding reach on the queries where a landing page genuinely fits, not standing in for the asset the buyer wanted.
#4 Video remains the most under-invested content format
When users are asking Google to see demos of non-branded solutions, the top AI-cited format is video (29%), beating out even listicles (20%). Additionally, the video carousel shows up on 93% of those same screens.
YouTube also feeds the AI Overview on 47% of all queries. One results page, two placements. It’s the #1 AI-cited domain, on 705 queries, but ranks on page 1 of organic results for just 123.

A product demo on YouTube is the single most underused bottom-funnel asset in this market. It’s the one format that can hold two placements on the same demo-intent screen, the AI Overview’s citations and the video carousel, while most competitors point all their budget at a paid landing page.
We’ve seen this work first-hand. We took a client’s existing product demo video, worked their non-branded keywords into it, and it earned a spot inside the AI Overview’s citations. No new production budget, no launch. Sometimes it’s a matter of optimizing what you’ve already got.
What does this mean for your go-to-market strategy?
YouTube isn’t purely a social channel here. It shows up in two places on the results page, the video carousel and the AI Overview citations, which makes it the second-largest search engine in this dataset as well as a content platform.
Whoever manages it should treat titles, descriptions, and chapter markers as search-optimization work, not just production, regardless of which team owns the channel.
#5 The review stage runs on community (and there’s no shortcut in)
One of the biggest winners in organic and AI isn’t a traditional publisher or vendor, but rather a community: Reddit. It’s the single biggest organic presence in the whole dataset, the #1 domain, reaching 693 queries, and the #2 source the AI cites (443).
It sits in the top six of all eight categories on both organic links and AI citations, and it is the #1 organic domain in five of them. While it is completely absent from paid and recommended brands in AI Overviews. Community supplies the reading material that search and AI are built on; it never makes the vendor shortlist and never buys its way in.
A discussions-and-forums block appears on 32% of all queries, but that average hides a sharp curve by intent: it climbs to 62% on review-intent queries, when a buyer is pressure-testing a shortlist they’ve already built, then falls to 0% at demo, once they’ve decided. Reddit alone drives most of it (29% of all queries, 59% at review intent); G2 and Quora supply the rest.

This is a channel you can’t own, can’t be recommended on, and can’t buy, only participate in, and the buyers reading it are at the highest-stakes moment in the funnel: deciding whether the shortlist the AI and the listicles handed them is actually any good.
The play isn’t a content calendar, its presence and accuracy. Treat Reddit and Quora as review-stage infrastructure, not social media.
What does this mean for your go-to-market strategy?
This is a cross-functional play, not any one team’s job. The work isn’t posting as the brand, it’s getting the customers who already use you to share use cases and troubleshoot in public, where buyers are looking. That reads as help, not promotion, and it compounds: every honest answer becomes the material the next buyer reads.
But tread lightly. Keep it genuine and never traded for a review, and don’t let it tip into a sales pitch. Push too hard or too promotionally, and you can get banned from somewhere like Reddit for good, which does more damage than staying out.
Conclusion: Organic, AI, and paid aren’t separate channels. They’re one screen, so manage them that way.
The brands pulling ahead don’t run Search, AI, and paid as separate programs, they coordinate them to occupy more of the same search results. Different teams, different budgets, attributed differently, but one buyer seeing them together. Expanding your share of those search results is the goal; the channels are just the levers that get you there.
Audit your brand across every web property, not just your main site.
A buyer’s shortlist research surfaces more than your homepage: your second and third YouTube channels, old landing pages, and blog posts the founder wrote in 2016 under a previous logo or tagline all show up too. If those carry outdated branding, a name you’ve since dropped, or messaging that contradicts what you say today, they undercut every channel you’ve worked to win.
Audit what’s actually indexed and cited under your brand, not just what you intended to publish, and fix or redirect whatever doesn’t match who you are now.
Win the third-party lists that feed both search and AI.
Third-party listicles are the #1 format at the comparison stage in both organic (55%) and AI (58%), and most live on sites you don’t own: G2, Gartner, PeopleManagingPeople, SelectSoftwareReviews. Review generation, profile management, analyst briefings, and editorial outreach get you into them, and because organic and AI reward the same lists, a single placement compounds across organic and AI at once.
Make one asset earn multiple stages of intent.
Because search and AI reward the same formats, the highest-ROI content does double duty: a category explainer wins MOFU on both features; a comparison page wins the comparison stage on both; a product demo on YouTube wins AI Overview, the video carousel, and demo-intent search at the same time.
The format hierarchy is consistent across every category we tracked: MOFU → articles and explainers, Comparison → third-party listicles, Demo → product pages and video, Paid → dedicated landing pages.
Point paid budget at the gaps you haven’t earned yet.
Paid is the one feature on the search results page you can buy instantly, and it’s almost always a landing page (68–82% of placements). Used well, it covers the parts of the screen your organic and AI presence don’t reach yet, and stacks with the ones they do, so a buyer sees you in the ad and the AI answer and the organic list.
Where to Start
Quick wins
- Audit your digital footprint on your top 20 high-intent queries; where you appear, how accurately, and whether you’re in the cited URLs across each search feature, against your top 3 competitors.
- Check which third-party listicles rank for those queries, and whether you’re in them.
- Update your G2 and Gartner profiles: reviews, positioning, category tags.
- Audit paid spend on queries where you already win organic or AI.
Build over 6–12 months
- Build stage-matched assets that win both organic and AI: explainers (MOFU), comparison pages, demo content.
- Stand up a video program for bottom-funnel queries (the content format most competitors ignore).
- Run a sustained review and analyst program to climb the third-party lists that define your category.
- Track your digital footprint across channels as one view (coverage, accuracy, and citation share), not three separate reports.
Want Flow to help audit your brand’s digital footprint?
We run a digital footprint audit across Google (ads, AI Overview, video, and organic) and AI platforms (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, etc) on the high-intent queries in your category.
You find out where your brand appears, whether AI and search describe it accurately, how often you turn up in the top cited URLs those answers are built from, and where competitors are out-covering you. Two weeks, and a clear brief for the next 12 months.
You can book a call to learn more about the audit and services here!
Appendix and Methodology
What we measured
The Search Visibility Index maps competitive visibility across the three discovery surfaces a buyer sees on a single Google results page, read consistently across categories and buyer intents.
Using Google allowed us to review 3 channels in one capture: Organic (Google top-10), AI (the AI Overview, split into the sources it cites and the brands it names), and Paid (the ad block).
We ran 1,500 non-branded keywords covering 6 search intents focused around the purchasing cycle through SerpApi in June 2026 (US, English). These intents included middle of funnel, bottom of funnel, comparative, pricing, reviews and demo.
Example of the types of keywords:

The keywords were selected through browsing top-ranking categories in Work Tech SaaS across review sites such as G2, Capterra, and Gartner. The initial list was used to expand across the funnel. The keyword set is balanced across categories (166–211 each), so comparisons aren’t distorted by sample size. And keywords were validated through Ahrefs, as only those with visible search volume were used in this study.
Software categories reviewed:
- Frontline & Deskless Workforce
- L&D and Upskilling
- Talent Acquisition & AI Recruiting
- HRIS & Core People Platforms
- Payroll & Benefits
- Performance, Engagement & Culture
- People Analytics & Workforce Intelligence
- Global Employment & EOR
We captured 32,990 URLs which were then reviewed and classified into one of 20 page types. For simplicity’s sake, the published study and gated report focused on the top 6 page types (Listicle, Article, Product, Landing page, Video, Review site)
How AI helped us run this study
This study was built to run at a scale manual analysis can’t reach, and to be re-run as AI search shifts. AI did the heavy lifting: classifying [N] SERPs and [N] pages by type and intent, and extracting brand mentions across [N] queries. The judgment stayed human. We designed the questions, wrote the classification rules, and checked the output over two rounds of QA, where the page-type pipeline landed at ~92% accuracy. What we’re left with is a repeatable pipeline, not a one-off snapshot: point it at a fresh set of queries, and it runs the same way.





